Roshan MascarenhasRoshan Mascarenhas asked 11 months ago
  •  
2 Answers
RaviRavi Staff answered 11 months ago

i am not happy with suggested answer. it seems incorrect i have mailed it to icai, but no reply yet. below is text and important documents regarding it.
 
Dear Sir / Madam
 
Once a person becomes Chartered Accountant, he cannot take ca related work in “any other capacity” is explained in code of ethics through a income tax practitioner case.
 
But in Q5(a) on CA Final New Course May 18 & Page 20.15 / 20.16 concepts explained are contradictory. As per them CA can work in different capacities even it is regular tax work. Please see two documents attached below.
 
 
Significance of COP as per Code of Ethics
 
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1oPXT1q77Ug8ygkZpDAek0Hgqlfs6wnvo/view?usp=sharing
 
Q5(a) Suggested Answer as per ICAI
 
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yq5ffSjkLPvLrNHtqvv6W4pB-6Tbco43/view?usp=sharing

Roshan MascarenhasRoshan Mascarenhas answered 11 months ago

Thanks